Wednesday, January 8, 2014

Sallie Ottavino Elkordy

Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dSr

Sallie O. Elkordy, while a long-time activist, is a relative newcomer to the anti-vaccine ranks.

As of 2013, she and her sisters were the principals in a New York based stone-working company started by her grandfather, Adamo Ottavino, in 1913. The Managing Partner is her husband,  Muhamed Elkordy.

According to her family company's website,
"Sallie Ottavino Elkordy holds a Master of Architecture degree from The Catholic University of America in Washington, DC and a Bachelor of Fine Arts from New York University.  Also known as "Sillie Sallie", she is the founder/director of the Museum of Comedy, a non-profit organization serving hospitals and homeless shelters throughout NYC.  Mrs. Elkordy has produced over 900 comedy shows on her "Mission of Cheer" since 1993. 
Somewhere along the way Ms. Elkordy began believing in a number of highly implausible conspiracy theories, such as "chemtrails" and a secret masterplan to "geoengineer" the world. 

In 2011, Ms. Elkordy ran as an independent write-in candidate  for the 9th New York Congressional District in Brooklyn and Queens. The campaign did not succeed.

In 2012, Ms. Elkordy launched the "Billion Toddler March for Survival" and a campaign to ban vaccines in New York, claiming

Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dUW













Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dUW









Text:
Hi everyone, vaccines are injuring and killing our children.  I am beyond concerned with the current vaccine schedule because 49 vaccines are being recommended up to age six. Consider that one shot to an infant is the equivalent of 30 to an adult on the same day and you will get the full impacto f the threat that vaccines pose to our children. The legislation I have written on my blog http://billiontoddlermarchforsurvival.blogspot.com states the ingredients (which are poisonous) and the disease that result from these ingredients as well as the intent to cause these diseases.



Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dUW





















Text:
Proposed Legislation, ”BAN VACCINES 2013!”
Submit to Legislators at all levels of Government because of the
1) Ingredients, or 2) Diseases, or 3) Intent, or all three reasons:
1) TOXIC INGREDIENTS FOUND IN VACCINES: * aluminum hydroxide * aluminum phosphate * ammonium sulfate * amphotericin B * animaltissues: pig blood, horse blood, rabbit brain * dog kidney, monkey kidney* chick embryo, chicken egg, duck egg * calf (bovine) serum * betapropiolactone * fetal bovine serum * formaldehyde * formalin * gelatin *glycerol * human diploid cells (originating from human aborted fetaltissue) * hydrolized gelatin * mercury thimerosol (thimerosal,Merthiolate) * monosodium glutamate (MSG) * neomycin * neomycin sulfate *phenol red indicator * phenoxyethanol (antifreeze) * potassiumdiphosphate * potassium monophosphate * polymyxin B * polysorbate 20 *polysorbate 80 porcine (pig) pancreatic hydrolysate of casein * residual MRC5 proteins * sorbitol * tri(n)butylphosphate * VERO cells, a continuous line ofmonkey kidney cells * washed sheep red blood (source on page 2 of http://www.reversingvaccineinduceddiseases.com/files/3638448/uploaded/Physicians-Warranty-of-Vaccine-Safety.pdf) plus * LIVE VIRUSES * recently, ANTHRAX Vaccine has been approved for testing on Children (subsequent to The Presidential Commission on BioEthics meeting of 1/15/13)
2) DISEASES FROM VACCINES: * Allergies * Asthma * Attention Deficit Disorder
*Autism * Auto-immune Diseases * Blindness * Brain Cell Loss *Cancer * Central
Nervous System Damage * Deafness * Developmental Damage *DEATH * Diabetes
* Epilepsy * Learning Disabilities * Leukemia * Multiple Sclerosis * Neurological
Disease * Organ Disease * Psoriasis * Seizures * Shaken Baby Syndrome
* Synergistic Toxicity * SIDS * Total Paralysis * All Diseases in Internal Medicine
3-A) INTENT: “The Vaccine Hoax is Over” by Andrew Baker about FOIA findings.
Dr. Tomljenovic's full paper can be downloaded here on pdf format:
http://www.ecomed.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/3-tomljenovic.pdf"Freedom of Information Act in the UK filed by a doctor there has
revealed 30 years of secret official documents showing that government
experts have
1. Known the vaccines don’t work
2. Known they cause the diseases they are supposed to prevent
3. Known they are a hazard to children
4. Colluded to lie to the public
5. Worked to prevent safety studies
Those are the same vaccines that are mandated to children in the US.”
Full article by Andrew Baker with recommended ACTIONS (see items 1 and 2):
http://foodfreedomgroup.com/2012/09/29/the-vaccine-hoax-is-over-by-andrew-baker/

Image Source
http://www.donotlink.com/dVh





















Petitioned Congress
VACCINE VICTIMS MEMORIAL on the National Mall in Washington, DC
Petition by
SALLIE O. ELKORDY
NEW YORK, NY
Our Government has been coerced into believing that Vaccines are beneficial, although there is a preponderance of evidence to the contrary. Children, above all others, have been targeted to receive these inoculations and we must stop further vaccine related injuries and death by raising awareness in honoring these children. October is International Vaccine Injury Awareness Month, so let's try to have our own National Memorial to Vaccine Victims installed by October of next year (2012). A design competition will commence in October 2011 and parents of vaccine injured children and architects will evaluate the designs to choose a suitable Memorial to all the children. The idea of a Memorial to Vaccine Victims was inspired by http://www.NVIC.org.  International Vaccine Injury Awareness Month was created with http://TruthAboutGardasil.org .
Thanks to Congress for taking action to raise awareness about Vaccine Injury as a preventative measure, by proposing and passing legislation which will permit the construction of this memorial on the National Mall in Washington, DC..

All of the above is nonsense, of course.

Some of the people Sallie Elkordy likes and promotes:



To summarize, I think we can safely say a person or organization is anti-vaccine if he or she exhibits at least three of the following points.
  1. Claiming that all vaccines are unsafe and ineffective Yes
  2. Claiming better sanitation and nutrition account for the 20th century decline in vaccine-preventable diseases Unknown
  3. Claiming that vaccines cause diseases and conditions such as autism, asthma, SIDS, or shaken baby syndrome Yes
  4. Claiming that anecdotal evidence is superior to scientific evidence; rejecting science and epidemiology Yes
  5. Cherry picking and misrepresenting the evidence Yes
  6. Using  logical fallacies without shame in arguing Yes
  7. Conspiracy mongering Yes
  8. Silencing criticism (especially by deleting onlin material), rather than responding to it Unknown
  9. (If in business) Profiting from the sale of products and services that spread fear, uncertainty and doubt about vaccines, or products and services that are said to be superior to vaccines and conventional medicine in preventing disease No
Score:
7/9

Summary: 
Elkordy would be a trivial figure in the anti-vaccine movement if it weren't for how well-funded she is.  She amplifies other second-tier figures (who we will discuss later) such as Rebecca Carley, "Madame Ghis" (formerly Ghislaine Lanctôt) and others. 

Sources

Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Lowell Kevin Hubbs

Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dQ8
Lowell Hubbs is a resident of South Dakota who has made it his life's mission to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about the safety and efficacy of vaccines.

Mr. Hubbs has been a frequent commenter on blog posts and mainstream media posts about autism, or about vaccination issues, for the last decade.

His comments consist almost entirely of fact-free rants, conspiracy theories, and insults to others.

Evidently, Mr. Hubbs has a high school diploma and no further education in science or medicine (source).

In 2011, Mr. Hubbs falsely claimed that his site, lowellsfacts.com had been taken down by Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Here is an analysis of the facts of the matter at Ars Technica, No, ICE didn’t seize your domain; you’ve just been punked.

Mr. Hubbs is a great fan and supporter of other anti-vaccine second-tier figures such as Mary Tocco and Sherri Tenpenny, who we will cover in later posts.

Mr. Hubbs has several (perhaps as many as five) convictions for Driving Under the Influence (DUI).  This post has images of several of the convictions.

To summarize, I think we can safely say a person or organization is anti-vaccine if he or she exhibits at least three of the following points. Let's tot up Mr. Hubbs's score
  1. Claiming that all vaccines are unsafe and ineffective Yes
  2. Claiming better sanitation and nutrition account for the 20th century decline in vaccine-preventable diseases Yes
  3. Claiming that vaccines cause diseases and conditions such as autism, asthma, SIDS, or shaken baby syndrome Yes
  4. Claiming that anecdotal evidence is superior to scientific evidence; rejecting science and epidemiology Yes
  5. Cherry picking and misrepresenting the evidence Yes
  6. Using  logical fallacies without shame in arguing Yes
  7. Conspiracy mongering Yes
  8. Silencing criticism (especially by deleting onlin material), rather than responding to it Yes
  9. (If in business) Profiting from the sale of products and services that spread fear, uncertainty and doubt about vaccines, or products and services that are said to be superior to vaccines and conventional medicine in preventing disease No
Score:
8/9. 
Summary: 
Hubbs is a would be a trivial, if offensive, figure in the anti-vaccine movement if it weren't for how active he is in comments. His false allegations have to be countered, even if they aren't in shouting distance of reality.


Sources

Monday, January 6, 2014

Erwin Alber

Image Source
http://www.donotlink.com/dDH
Irwin Alber is a Swiss-born anti-vaccine activist who has been campaigning against vaccines (according to his own account) since 1988.

At some point prior to 1995, he joined what was then called the New Zealand Immunisation Awareness Society Incorporated (IAS), and worked with the German anti-vaccination MD Gerhard Buchwald to translate Buchwald's screeds into English.

In the late 1990s, Alber had a quarterly publication called Informed Choices, with circulation in the hundreds.

At some point prior to 2009, Alber moved to Thailand where he is evidently a teacher in a bilingual school.  As of July 2013 he was resident in Thailand.

According to the July 2013 interview (linked below) Alber's academic training was at an agricultural college.  That's it.  No training in immunology or vaccinology or public health.

Alber became anti-vaccine as a consequence of reading a book on animal experimentation, which convinced him that all vaccines are a conspiracy.

Alber's opinons on the safety, efficacy, and utility of vaccines can be summed up with the following quotes:
There is no such thing as a vaccine-preventable disease because vaccines don't prevent, but promote ill-health. 

Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dDP










"I have arrived at the inevitable conclusion that vaccination is an organised criminal enterprise dressed up as disease prevention by means of junk science. 
The claim that vaccines had something to do with the decline of infectious disease mortality is an absolute lie. 

Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dDP











Anti-Vaccine Checklist: How Does Alber Score? (a person or organization is anti-vaccine if he or she exhibits at least three of the following points.
  1. Claiming that all vaccines are unsafe and ineffective Yes
  2. Claiming better sanitation and nutrition account for the 20th century decline in vaccine-preventable diseases Yes
  3. Claiming that vaccines cause diseases and conditions such as autism, asthma, SIDS, or shaken baby syndrome Yes
  4. Claiming that anecdotal evidence is superior to scientific evidence; rejecting science and epidemiology 
  5. Cherry picking and misrepresenting the evidence Yes
  6. Using  logical fallacies without shame in arguing Yes
  7. Conspiracy mongering Yes
  8. Silencing criticism (especially by deleting online material), rather than responding to it
  9. (If in business) Profiting from the sale of products and services that spread fear, uncertainty and doubt about vaccines, or products and services that are said to be superior to vaccines and conventional medicine in preventing disease Unknown
Score:
8/9.

Summary: 
Alber would be a trivial, if offensive, figure in the anti-vaccine movement if it weren't for the VINE Facebook page, which as of January 2014 had in excess of 100,000 "likes" and is a very active community, in which conspiracy theories, "cures", and horror stories are exchanged.


Disambiguation: There is a aerospace consultant based in California named Irwin Alber; this page is not about Dr. Alber.

Sources note: some URLs use donotlink

Friday, January 3, 2014

Tedd Koren, DC

Image Source
http://www.donotlink.com/dBC
For my money, Tedd Koren is one of the most effective propagandists for the anti-vaccine movement.  But he is barely on the radar of the skeptical movement.

To the best of my knowledge, none of his published materials have ever been debunked nor have his many false and exaggerated claims

Tedd Koren is a 1977 graduate of the Sherman College of Chiropractic (a member of the second graduating class of that institution) in Spartanburg, South Carolina.

From 1977-1988, he was primarily in private practice as a chiropractor, in and around Philadelphia, PA.

Beginning in 1987, he founded Koren Publications, and began publishing "patient information packages" for chiropractors, including leaflets, booklets, books, and videos.(Koren earned a BA in communications from the University of Miami.) Among these materials were (and are) anti-vaccine screeds, designed to alarm parents into refusing vaccination, and larger packages for chiropractors to use to scare patients away from vaccination and into chiropractic care.

On January 10, 1995, Koren received a seven-page letter from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), requiring that he substantiate claims made in materials published and distributed by Koren Publications, including claims about chiropractic and infectious disease, and claims about the dangers of vaccination.

Sadly, the FTC eventually dropped the investigation, allowing Koren to continue to market such gems as


In addition to the widely reproduced posters (samples below).

Anti-Vaccine Checklist: How Does Koren Score? (a person or organization is anti-vaccine if he or she exhibits at least three of the following points.
  1. Claiming that all vaccines are unsafe and ineffective Yes
  2. Claiming better sanitation and nutrition account for the 20th century decline in vaccine-preventable diseases Yes
  3. Claiming that vaccines cause diseases and conditions such as autism, asthma, SIDS, or shaken baby syndrome Yes
  4. Claiming that anecdotal evidence is superior to scientific evidence; rejecting science and epidemiology 
  5. Cherry picking and misrepresenting the evidence Yes
  6. Using  logical fallacies without shame in arguing Yes
  7. Conspiracy mongering Yes
  8. Silencing criticism (especially by deleting online material), rather than responding to it
  9. (If in business) Profiting from the sale of products and services that spread fear, uncertainty and doubt about vaccines, or products and services that are said to be superior to vaccines and conventional medicine in preventing disease Yes
Score:
8/9.

Summary

I believe that Tedd Koren is one of the most influential people in the anti-vaccine movement, because of the reach and ubiquity of his publications.

Image source
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=247x26631





















Image Source, Koren Publications,
http://www.donotlink.com/dBUhttp://www.donotlink.com/dBU

Image Source:
http://www.donotlink.com/dCy














































The skeptical movement and anti-vaccination propaganda


Source: http://www.randi.org/site/index.php/swift-blog/1361-my-skeptic-elevator-pitch.html














Sources

Thursday, January 2, 2014

Is There An Anti-Vaccination Movement?

For my money, the answer is no and yes.

No, in the sense that there's not a central organization, issuing diktats and marching orders, and determining if this person or that person is worthy of membership in the movement.

Yes, in the sociological sense, as outlined by Professor Timothy Gongaware:

source: http://www.uwlax.edu/faculty/gongaware/collbeh/cbdefinitions.htm
As we saw in the post, What Are "Anti-Vaccine"Hallmarks, people who are anti-vaccine share some beliefs and habits of thought.

As we go forward, we might also begin to see some patterns of relationships between individuals and organizations -- overlapping memberships, attendance at each other's meetings and conventions, support for various enterprises and activism opportunities, and so on.

What Are The Hallmarks of the "Anti-Vaccine" Ideology?

What defines someone as anti-vaccinist? There's no one, agreed-upon definition.

Robert Todd Carroll at the excellent Skeptics Dictionary has a long, discursive entry on some of the aspects of being against vaccination, in the entry Anti-Vaccine Movement. He notes at least two prongs:
  1. Those who "deny a causal connection between vaccines and the eradication or significant reduction of diseases like smallpox, polio, measles, and rubella."  (The "vaccines didn't save us" myth.)
  2. Those who believe that receipt of vaccines cause disease. One example is the cadre who continue to believe that the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine can cause autism. 
David Gorski, MD, writing at another excellent resource, Science-Based Medicine, published  What does “anti-vaccine” really mean? on November 1, 2010, in which he discusses the various nuances in the anti-vaccine community.  he has a simple litmus test:
....one rather reliable way of differentiating fear from real anti-vaccine views is to ask a simple question: Which vaccines do you think that, barring medical contraindications, children should receive? If the answer is “none,” then I’m pretty much done. I know I’m almost certainly dealing with an anti-vaccinationist. 
 Gorski goes on to draw a distinction between the vaccine-hesitant (those who have fears about vaccine safety and efficacy) from more committed vaccine-refusers and denialists.  The latter category of people have some hallmarks in their thinking:
  • Denying that they are anti-vaccine ("No, I'm pro-safe vaccine", while denying that there are any vaccines that are both safe and necessary.)
  • Generally relying on logical fallacies.
  • Frequent use of the  Nirvana fallacy, "wherein if something is not perfect it is claimed to be utterly worthless." (The flu vaccine is often dismissed with this fallacy.)
  • Intense reliance on "false cause" reasoning (formally, "post hoc ergo propter hoc" fallacy.)
  • Attributing harms to the vaccine that the "scientific data definitely don’t support as being reasonable or legitimate." (This is Carroll's point #2.)
  • Distortion of the scientific evidence, especially using cherry picking of the scientific evidence
  • Exaggeration of the risks of vaccines relative to the risks of suffering a vaccine-preventable disease.
  • Prizing anecdotal evidence over more careful science ("Thousands of parents who saw their children suffer vaccine injury can't be wrong")
  • Reliance on conspiracy theories to explain away inconstancies
  • Reliance upon aggression (attacks on character) and silencing (shouting down, deleting comments) rather than engaging in honest exchanges of views. 
To summarize, I think we can safely say a person or organization is anti-vaccine if he or she exhibits at least three of the following points.
  1. Claiming that all vaccines are unsafe and ineffective
  2. Claiming better sanitation and nutrition account for the 20th century decline in vaccine-preventable diseases
  3. Claiming that vaccines cause diseases and conditions such as autism, asthma, SIDS, or shaken baby syndrome
  4. Claiming that anecdotal evidence is superior to scientific evidence; rejecting science and epidemiology
  5. Cherry picking and misrepresenting the evidence
  6. Using  logical fallacies without shame in arguing
  7. Conspiracy mongering
  8. Silencing criticism (especially by deleting onlin material), rather than responding to it
  9. (If in business) Profiting from the sale of products and services that spread fear, uncertainty and doubt about vaccines, or products and services that are said to be superior to vaccines and conventional medicine in preventing disease

Wednesday, January 1, 2014

Why This Blog?

This blog is frankly modeled on The Encyclopedia of American Loons (EAL), which chronicles all kinds of folks having ideas that are not grounded in reality.

Recently, many more people have become interested in the anti-vaccine movement, which is international in scope.  Sometimes it is difficult to know who is who, so several of us thought that we should share our background knowledge about the leading lights and lesser luminaries.

Finally, frankly, this effort really should be a wiki, and may become so in the course of time.